PARIS — The most recent in a collection of controversies which have surrounded the renovation of Notre-Dame unfolded on Thursday, when a fee of heritage specialists gave the inexperienced mild to a revamp of the inside of the fire-stricken cathedral.
France’s Nationwide Heritage and Structure Fee authorized proposals by the diocese of Paris to deliver a extra trendy look to Notre-Dame earlier than its deliberate reopening in 2024, together with the set up of latest artworks and new lighting results. Opponents say the adjustments will debase the 850-year-old cathedral and disturb the concord of its Gothic design.
The heritage fee additionally licensed cathedral directors to rearrange the tabernacle and different objects to create extra room for guests. Msgr. Patrick Chauvet, Notre-Dame’s rector, stated the proposals would permit for a better and extra nice go to to the spiritual monument and create “a dialogue” between Notre-Dame’s medieval structure and new, extra trendy options.
Artworks from the twentieth and twenty first centuries could possibly be positioned subsequent to previous grasp work from the cathedral’s assortment, equivalent to Mathieu Le Nain’s “Nativity of the Virgin Mary,” Chauvet stated.
He added that the diocese was additionally contemplating mild projections on the partitions of some chapels that will show quick textual content excerpts from the Bible.
A lot of the confessionals could be moved to the primary ground within the rearrangement of the cathedral’s 2,000 or so furnishings objects, Chauvet stated, and Notre-Dame’s greater than 12 million annual guests would now enter by the central portal as a substitute of by way of a aspect door.
“The concept is that the trustworthy, or guests, are first struck by the grandeur, by the fantastic thing about Notre-Dame,” Chauvet stated.
But the addition of contemporary touches threatens to disfigure the cathedral, based on dozens of cultural figures and intellectuals who’ve stood up towards the proposals.
Notre-Dame has already gone by greater than two years of cautious restoration efforts, after a blaze tore by it in April 2019, destroying the spire and a lot of the roof. The constructing has now been secured sufficient to begin the rebuilding course of, which is anticipated to be accomplished simply in time for the 2024 Olympics in Paris.
French authorities initially contemplated seizing the chance to considerably rework the cathedral’s structure. Heritage specialists ultimately really useful that the monument be restored to its prior state and, final 12 months, President Emmanuel Macron dropped the concept to switch the Nineteenth-century spire with one thing extra modern.
On Tuesday, about 100 public figures in France signed their names to an open letter within the conservative newspaper Le Figaro titled “Notre-Dame de Paris: What the hearth spared, the diocese desires to destroy.”
The signatories, who embody Alain Finkielkraut and Pierre Nora from the distinguished Académie Française, stated some proposals recalled “‘immersive’ cultural tasks the place, typically, inanity vies with kitsch.”
Le Monde newspaper stated the proposals had led to a fierce battle inside the French Catholic Church between “advocates of modernity and ecumenism and the guardians of a nostalgic conservatism.”
Some conservative British newspapers seized on passages within the redevelopment plan about creating “emotional areas” and “a discovery tour.” A headline in The Every day Telegraph stated that Notre-Dame confronted a “woke Disney revamp.”
Didier Rykner, the editor in chief of the artwork journal La Tribune de l’Artwork and one of many signatories of the open letter in Le Figaro, stated that criticism within the British press was based mostly on caricatures, however that he agreed with their normal thrust.
“The church is 2,000 years previous — it’s an previous girl,” he stated. “It has a historical past that we should respect, that right this moment’s individuals can not erase with a stroke of the pen.”
The heritage fee could have heard a number of the criticism. It didn’t settle for the proposal put earlier than it by the diocese in full, and rejected or questioned some components. The committee denied a request, as an example, to take away statues of saints from a number of chapels. It additionally requested for a overview of a design for detachable benches that have been proposed as a substitute for the cathedral’s conventional picket chairs, based on a press release issued Thursday by the minister of tradition.
Chauvet stated that the adjustments to Notre-Dame’s inside weren’t revolutionary and would solely “deliver slightly extra sense to the guests.”
“Don’t assume we’re going to make Disneyland,” he stated.
